Woulda Coulda Shoulda

Opinion Would Coulda Shoulda
#1

I thought it was about time for another series of rankings. Introducing the woulda coulda shoulda ranking lists.

THE WOULDA RANKING.
This next ranking is by points for if people played the worst possible lineup (excluding injured/obvious non starters) They woulda had this many points if they had to play their worst lineup. NOTE: This list removes one player that was actually played anyway (cough…melton…cough).

  1. Chasen @chasenrogers 66.0
  2. Garrett @gbhart 64.4
  3. Jon @jonathan 60.2
  4. Alex @Alex 54.5
  5. Ventura @ventura 54.4
  6. Stock @mikeastock 2.1
  7. Amunrud 43.9
  8. Melton @awmelman 42.3
  9. Paul @PaulDawg 42.0
  10. Charbonnet @IanC 41.6

THE COULDA RANKING.
This rank is total points for played and benched players if everyone coulda played all players.

  1. Chasen 232.4
  2. Charbonnet 190.9
  3. Amunrud 183.5
  4. Ventura 181.5
  5. Garrett 155.0
  6. Jon 149.6
  7. Alex 148.8
  8. Paul 144.3
  9. Stock 141.6
  10. Melton 129.1

THE SHOULDA RANKING.
My first list for you is the ranking of teams (by points for) based on the optimal lineups they shoulda played.

  1. Chasen 158.7
  2. Charbonnet 147.1
  3. Jon 129.5
  4. Amunrud 128.1
  5. Ventura 123.5
  6. Garrett 115.0
  7. Alex 109.3
  8. Stock 105.5
  9. Melton 102.6
  10. Paul 95.3

FUN FACT: If all teams had optimal lineups it would only change the outcome of 1 matchup. Me vs Stock.

BEST TEAM MANAGERS FOR WEEK 1.
This list ranks the coaches by order of smallest differential between the optimal and starting line ups.

  1. Stock (-8.3)
  2. Alex (-10.9)
  3. Garrett (-15.4)
  4. Paul (-20.3)
  5. Jon (-26.1)
  6. Chasen (-26.7)
  7. Melton (-31.6)
  8. Amunrud (-32.5)
  9. Ventura (-33.4)
  10. Charbonnet (-48.3)

Tune in sometime next week (or later this week) for another pointless series of useless rankings that are kinda fun to probably only me!

1 Like
#2

I beat Paul in literally every single category. I feel so good about myself now.

#3

@Chasen was at the top of every list except for the manager one, although the team he fielded did well enough to beat 5/10 of the optimal teams. Wow. Good luck next week Charbs.

Also, just pointing out I was the only one to vote for Chasen having the most points this week.

2 Likes
#4

You have my thanks jonathan. It is support like this that will carry me through my campaign to the top

1 Like
#5

In all honesty tho @ianamunrud, I love these rankings. Thanks for putting the work into these

3 Likes
#6

I look forward to playing a worthy opponent like @chasenrogers. I fear though, that last week’s mayhem may not be standard for his team :slight_smile: we shall see.

#7

lol